Stock rally or bluff ?
These past 2 days the DOW jones rallied by almost 700 points because of news coming out from Citigroup leaked memo and Bank of America’s CEO Ken Lewis optimism. Citigroup’s Vikram Pandit is saying that they are returning to profit in Jan and Feb 2009 and it was communicated in their internal memo, while BoA Ken Lewis was saying that they will have revenue of 100Billion in 2009 with 50% profit of 50Billion.
All financial jargon asides let’s dissect the news to see if it makes. Since mid last year we have been hearing news that both these banks are not making profits at all and they are receiving money from governtment, now my business sense is telling me that if you throw money into a failing company maybe it will help and even if it helps there is NO WAY you can make so much money in a short time period, profits and losses are accumulated over time and this can only happen if there are demands for the goods and services that we are selling. Citigroup and BoA are selling debt and at the moment the world and economic conditions are not supportive of the current condition where debt defaults are increasing day by day.
Take for example personal loans which depends on people having their jobs - now if they don’t have jobs what are they going to pay to the banks ? with unemployment rate going up every month and jobless claims are always on the rise do you think people have the money to pay down their debt ? jobless people will think I’m going to use the money to survive in this world not paying down my debt.
Same with commercial loans business have the ability to just declare bankrupt and take whatever they owe by liquidating their assets, now if you own a business and the business is not making money do you want to continue your business ? do you think banks going to give you more credit if you are not repaying the existing loans on time ? forget it.
With this logical explanation the news from these two banks does not make any logical sense because the other factors that they rely on does not support it. My gut feeling is telling me that this could be short covering and some short term investor jumping in to grab quick profit, in the few days to come the market will resume it’s downward movement again and will stay low for quite some time.
Comments(0)